Fray Symposium -
CD-FraySymposium_Volume1
CD shopping page

2011-Sustainable Industrial Processing Summit
SIPS2011 Volume 1: Sustainable Non-ferrous Smelting in 21st Century

Editors:Florian K
Publisher:Flogen Star OUTREACH
Publication Year:2012
Pages:828 pages
ISBN:978-0-9879917-0-6
ISSN:2291-1227 (Metals and Materials Processing in a Clean Environment Series)


  1. Using Pre-concentrate Nickel-iron Ore of Nickel Laterite to Make Low Ferronickel
     Deqing ZHU1; Jian PAN1; ZHOU Xianlin1; Xiaofeng XU2;
    1CENTRAL SOUTH UNIVERSITY, Changsha, China; 2CHINA ENFI ENGINEERING CORPORATION, Beijing, China;
    Type of Paper: Regular
    Id Paper: 32
    Topic: 4

  2. An Update On The Application Of MRT To Separations Of Interest In Metals Processing
     Neil Izatt1;
    1IBC ADVANCED TECHNOLOGIES, American Fork, United States;
    Type of Paper: Regular
    Id Paper: 39
    Topic: 4

  3. Influence Of Mechanical Vibration On Grain Refinement Of Copper Solidification
     Yanbing ZONG1; Daqiang Cang1; Chen Wang1;
    1UNIVERSITY OF SCIENCE AND TECHNOLOGY BEIJING, Beijing, China;
    Type of Paper: Regular
    Id Paper: 522
    Topic: 4

  4. The Prospect Of A Two-zone Vaniukov's Furnace Use For Processing Of Raw Material Con-taining Heavy Non-ferrous Metals
     Leonid Tsymbulov1; Mickail Knyazev1; Lev Tsemekhman1;
    1GIPRONICKEL INSTITUTE, Saint-Petersburg, Russia;
    Type of Paper: Regular
    Id Paper: 237
    Topic: 4

  5. Structure And Properties Of Slag Produced In The Course Of Continuous Converting Of Nickel Containing Copper Matte And Concentrates
     Leonid Tsymbulov1; Florian Kongoli2; Sergey Pigarev1; Eugene Selivanov3;
    1GIPRONICKEL INSTITUTE, Saint-Petersburg, Russia; 2FLOGEN TECHNOLOGIES INC., Mont-Royal, Canada; 3INSTITUTE OF METALLURGY URD RAS, YEKATERINBURG, Ekaterinburg, Russia;
    Type of Paper: Invite
    Id Paper: 238
    Topic: 4

  6. A Comparison Between Fluidized And Packed Bed Reactors In Non-Catalytic Gas-Solid Reactions
     Behnam Khoshandam1;
    1SEMNAN UNIVERSITY, Semnan, Iran;
    Type of Paper: Regular
    Id Paper: 70
    Topic: 4

  7. Mathematical Modeling Of Fluidized-Bed Reactors Used In Non-Catalytic Gas-Solid Reactions
     Behnam Khoshandam1; Samaneh Maroufi1; Ramachandran Kumar2;
    1SEMNAN UNIVERSITY, Semnan, Iran; 2UNIVERSITY OF CAMBRIDGE, Cambridge, United Kingdom;
    Type of Paper: Invite
    Id Paper: 72
    Topic: 4

  8. Environmentally Friendly Technologies For Manufacturing Pure Metals
     Aleksandre Kandelaki1; Omar Mikadze1; Jondo Bagdavadze1; Leri Rukhadze1;
    1F.TAVADZE INSTITUTE OF METALLURGY AND MATERIALS SC, Tbilisi, Georgia;
    Type of Paper: Regular
    Id Paper: 82
    Topic: 4

  9. Dissolution Mechanism Of Indium In Molten Ca0 - Si02 - Al203 Slag
     KyuYeol Ko1; Joohyun Park1;
    1UNIVERSITY OF ULSAN, Ulsan, Korea, South;
    Type of Paper: Regular
    Id Paper: 85
    Topic: 4

  10. Phase Equilibrium Analysis For The System CaO-SiO2-PbO-ZnO-FeO-Fe2O3 At CaO/SiO2 = 1.0 To 1.6 And Fe/SiO2 = 1.1 To 1.7
     Miguel Perez-Labra1; Antonio Romero-Serrano2; Aurelio Hernandez Ramirez1; Isaias Almaguer-G.3; Ricardo Benavides3;
    1ESIQIE-IPN, MEXICO D.F., Mexico; 2ESIQIE-IPN, Mexico, Mexico; 3SERVICIOS ADMINISTRATIVOS PENOLES, TORREON, Mexico;
    Type of Paper: Regular
    Id Paper: 101
    Topic: 4

  11. Study On The Extraction Of Ti Element From Ti-containing Slags Through Selective Enrichment Method
     Zuotai Zhang1; Jing Li1; Xidong Wang1;
    1PEKING UNIVERSITY, Beijing, China;
    Type of Paper: Regular
    Id Paper: 108
    Topic: 4

  12. T-X-Y Diagrams With Kinematical Surfaces For Lead-free Soldering Systems
     Vasily Lutsyk1;
    1PHYSICAL PROBLEMS DEPARTMENT OF BSC RAS (SIBERIAN, Ulan-Ude, Russia;
    Type of Paper: Regular
    Id Paper: 110
    Topic: 4

  13. Three-phase Reaction Type Changing In Systems Ti-Ru-Ir And Zr-Ru-Ir
     Vasily Lutsyk1;
    1PHYSICAL PROBLEMS DEPARTMENT OF BSC RAS (SIBERIAN, Ulan-Ude, Russia;
    Type of Paper: Regular
    Id Paper: 112
    Topic: 4

  14. Basic Approaches To Working Out Of Processing Technologies For Rebellious Gold-bearing Ores Providing Competitiveness Of The Company In Present-day Conditions.
     Marat Zhunusov1;
    1POLYUS GOLD MINING COMPANY, Moscow, Russia;
    Type of Paper: Regular
    Id Paper: 135
    Topic: 4

  15. Optimal Design Of A Prototype To Produce Tin Powder
     Jose G. Rivera-Ordonez1; Cornelio De la Cruz-Guerra2; Israel Hernandez-Romero3;
    1UNAM, Mexico City, Mexico; 2UNIVERSIDAD AUTóNOMA DEL CARMEN, Ciudad del Carmen, Mexico; 3UNIVERSIDAD VERACRUZANA, Poza Rica, Mexico;
    Type of Paper: Regular
    Id Paper: 151
    Topic: 4

  16. Crystals Of Different Dispersity Competition In Invariant Reactions L+А+В=С, L+А=В+С
     Vasily Lutsyk1; Anna Zelenaya2;
    1PHYSICAL PROBLEMS DEPARTMENT OF BSC RAS (SIBERIAN, Ulan-Ude, Russia; 2PHYSICAL PROBLEMS DEPARTMENT, BURYAT SCIENTIFIC CE, , Russia;
    Type of Paper: Regular
    Id Paper: 159
    Topic: 4

  17. Disolution Behavior Of Platinum Group Metals Into Molten Slags
     Kazuki Morita1; TORU OKABE2;
    1THE UNIVERSITY OF TOKYO, Tokyo, Japan; 2INSTITUTE OF INDUSTRIAL SCIENCE, THE UNIVERSITY OF, Tokyo, Japan;
    Type of Paper: Invite
    Id Paper: 168
    Topic: 4

  18. Application Of Water Cooled Copper Elements For Non-ferrous Metallurgical Furnaces
     Tongxin Lu1;
    1OHUATEK LTD, Padasjoki, Finland;
    Type of Paper: Regular
    Id Paper: 169
    Topic: 4

  19. Thermodynamics Of Materials At A High-temperature Limit
     George Kaptay1;
    1UNIVERSITY OF MISKOLC, Miskolc, Hungary;
    Type of Paper: Invite
    Id Paper: 174
    Topic: 4

  20. Optimization Of Technological Process Of Obtaining Fe-Ni In Newco Ferronikeli Of Drenas
     Florian Kongoli1; Shefik Imeri2; Ioannis Gaitanos2; Naim Tahiraj2; Musa Rizaj3;
    1FLOGEN TECHNOLOGIES INC., Mont-Royal, Canada; 2NEWCO FERRONIKELI-DRENAS, Prishtina, Kosovo; 3UNIVERSITY OF PRISHTINA, Prishtina, Kosovo;
    Type of Paper: Invite
    Id Paper: 193
    Topic: 4

  21. Numerical Simulation Of The Slag-matte Distribution In A Peirce-Smith Converter
     Chris Aldrich1; Guven Akdogan1; Deside Chibwe1; Chris Aldrich1;
    1UNIVERSITY OF STELLENBOSCH, Stellenbosch, South Africa;
    Type of Paper: Regular
    Id Paper: 196
    Topic: 4

  22. Measurement Of Non-isothermal Oxygen Potentials In The Cu-Fe-Ca-S-O Liquid During The Reduction Of Chalcopyrite, Lime, And Carbon Mixtures
     Animesh Jha1; 2;
    1UNIVERSITY OF LEEDS, Leeds, United Kingdom; 2NATIONAL METALLURGICAL LABORATORY, Jharkhand, India;
    Type of Paper: Regular
    Id Paper: 200
    Topic: 4

  23. Novel Electrochemical Sensor For The Determination Of Hydrogen In Aluminium – From The Laboratory To The Shop Floor –From The Laboratory To The Shop Floor –
     Carsten Schwandt1; Matt Hills2; mark henson3;
    1UNIVERSITY OF CAMBRIDGE, Cambridge, United Kingdom; 2EMC LIMITED, Stafford, United Kingdom; 3DEPARTMENT OF MATERIALS SCIENCE AND METALLURGY, UN, , United Kingdom;
    Type of Paper: Keynote
    Id Paper: 206
    Topic: 4

  24. Recovery Of Cu And Mo From Copper Slag Cleaning Treatment
     Chavez-Alcala Jose-Federico1; Ricardo Sanchez-Alvarado1; Marco Zander2; Bern Friedrich2; Gustavo Ortega3; Antelmo Robles4; Servando Cantu-Cantu5;
    1ESIQIE-IPN, Mexico City, Mexico; 2IME-TECHNICAL UNIVERSITY AACHEN, Aachen, Germany; 3MINERA MEXICO, Mexico City, Mexico; 4MINERA MEXICO, Nacozary, Mexico; 5MINERA MEXICO, Nacozari, Mexico;
    Type of Paper: Regular
    Id Paper: 207
    Topic: 4

  25. Hafnium Sponge Sintering Kinetics
     Yakov S. Bataev1; Ilya Polovov1; Vladimir Volkovich1; Oleg I. Rebrin1; Maksim A. Ryzhkov1; Artemii A. Popov1; Trevor Griffiths2;
    1URAL FEDERAL UNIVERSITY, Ekaterinburg, Russia; 2REDSTON TREVOR CONSULTING LTD, Leeds, United Kingdom;
    Type of Paper: Regular
    Id Paper: 213
    Topic: 4

  26. Reaction Kinetics By Coherent Electromagnetic wave Energy At GHz
     Motoyasu Sato1;
    1NATIONAL INSTITUTE FOR FUSION SCIENCE, Toki-city, Japan;
    Type of Paper: Regular
    Id Paper: 222
    Topic: 4

  27. Implementation Of A Slide Gate System For Copper Tapping
     Klaus Gamweger1;
    1RHI AG, Leoben, Austria;
    Type of Paper: Regular
    Id Paper: 245
    Topic: 4

  28. De-oxidation Of TiOx Melt With Al And CaAl/Ca2Al Alloys
     Krzysztof Borowiec1;
    1RIO TINTO, Tracy, Canada;
    Type of Paper: Regular
    Id Paper: 269
    Topic: 4

  29. Ionic Liquid Cooling Technology In Metallurgical Furnaces
     Christine Wenzl1; Andreas Filzwieser2; Eva Raaber2;
    1METTOP GMBH, Leoben, Austria; 2METTOP GMBH, Leoben, Austria ;
    Type of Paper: Regular
    Id Paper: 268
    Topic: 4

  30. Tailor Made Basic Engineering By Thermodynamic Process Modeling In The Secondary Copper Metallurgy
     Stefan Konetschnik1; Christine Wenzl1; Ladislav Koncik2; Andreas Filzwieser3;
    1METTOP GMBH, Leoben, Austria; 2METTOP GMBH, 8700 Leoben, Austria ; 3METTOP GMBH, Leoben, Austria ;
    Type of Paper: Regular
    Id Paper: 273
    Topic: 4

  31. Process Intensification In Large Scale Gold Ore Roasters
     Thorsten Gerdes1; Monika Willert-Porada1; Nikola Anastasijevic2;
    1UNIVERSITY OF BAYREUTH, Bayreuth, Germany; 2OUTOTEC GMBH, Oberursel, Germany;
    Type of Paper: Regular
    Id Paper: 289
    Topic: 4

  32. Microwave Assisted Recovery Of Platinum
     Thorsten Gerdes1; Monika Willert-Porada1;
    1UNIVERSITY OF BAYREUTH, Bayreuth, Germany;
    Type of Paper: Regular
    Id Paper: 290
    Topic: 4

  33. Application Of Dynamic Simulations In Metallurgical Industries
     Dan Berkley1;
    1DB ENGINEERING, Mississauga, Canada;
    Type of Paper: Invite
    Id Paper: 291
    Topic: 4

  34. Reductant Reactivity For Chromite Reduction
     Rauf Hurman Eric1; Amit Bahalla1;
    1UNIVERSITY OF THE WITWATERSRAND, Johannesburg, South Africa;
    Type of Paper: Regular
    Id Paper: 297
    Topic: 4

  35. Retorts And The Production Of Metals. A Historical Review
     Fathi Habashi1;
    1LAVAL UNIVERISTY, Quebec City, Canada;
    Type of Paper: Invite
    Id Paper: 300
    Topic: 4

  36. Fayalite Based Slags: Metal Recovery And Utilization
     Xuan Wang1; Daneel Geysen2; Yiannis Pontikes2; Veselin Petkov3; Muxing Guo2; Tom Jones2; Bart Blanpain4; Tom van Gerven2; Koen Van Balen2;
    1KULEUVEN, Heverlee, Belgium; 2KULEUVEN, Leuven, Belgium; 3KULEUVEN, , Belgium; 4KULEUVEN, 3001 Heverlee, Belgium;
    Type of Paper: Regular
    Id Paper: 323
    Topic: 4

  37. Recovery of nuclear materials and rare-earths by sulfide method
     Akiichi Kigoshi1; Nobuaki Sato1; Akira Kirishima1;
    1TOHOKU UNIVERSITY, Sendai, Japan;
    Type of Paper: Regular
    Id Paper: 499
    Topic: 4

  38. Hydrometallurgical Process For The Recovery Of Manganese From Pelletized Silicomanganese Submerged Arc Furnace Dust
     Sydney Nkosi1; Joalet D. Steenkamp2; Dick R. Groot2; Johan P. Gous3;
    1ASSMANG LTD, Machadodorp, South Africa; 2UNIVERSITY OF PRETORIA, Pretoria, South Africa; 3TRANSALLOYS, eMalahleni, South Africa;
    Type of Paper: Regular
    Id Paper: 406
    Topic: 4

  39. Thermal conductivity of manganese bearing slags - an introduction
     Joalet Dalene Steenkamp1; P. Chris Pistorius2; Merete Tangstad3;
    1UNIVERSITY OF PRETORIA, Pretoria, South Africa; 2CARNEGIE MELLON UNIVERSITY, Pittsburgh, United States; 3NTNU, Trondheim, Norway;
    Type of Paper: Regular
    Id Paper: 405
    Topic: 4

  40. Simulating Actual FeNi Production
     harmen oterdoom1;
    1SMS SIEMAG, Duesseldorf, Germany;
    Type of Paper: Regular
    Id Paper: 328
    Topic: 4

  41. Refractory Applications In The Seccondary Lead Industry
     Alfred Spanring1;
    1RHI AG, Vienna, Austria ;
    Type of Paper: Regular
    Id Paper: 338
    Topic: 4

  42. Mathematical Simulation Of The Copper Drossing In Lead Bath With Sulphur Injection
     Víctor Hugo Gutiérrez Pérez1; Marissa Vargas Ramírez2; Alejandro Cruz-Ramirez3;
    1ESIQIE-IPN, D.F., Mexico; 2UAEH, Pachuca, Mexico; 3ESIQIE-IPN, D.F, Mexico;
    Type of Paper: Regular
    Id Paper: 345
    Topic: 4

  43. Reactive Gas Bubbling In Metals In A Hele-Shaw Cell
     Bart Klaasen1; Frederik Verhaeghe2; Jan Fransaer3; Bart Blanpain4;
    1KATHOLIEKE UNIVERSITEIT LEUVEN, Heverlee, Belgium; 2UMICORE R&D, B-2250 Olen, Belgium; 3KATHOLIEKE UNIVERSITEIT LEUVEN, B-3001 Leuven, Belgium; 4KULEUVEN, 3001 Heverlee, Belgium;
    Type of Paper: Regular
    Id Paper: 347
    Topic: 4

  44. Fluid Dynamics Study Of The Roasting Of Zinc Sulfide Concentrate In A Fluidized Bed Reactor
     Francisco Moura1; Roberto Carvalho1;
    1PUC-RIO, Rio de Janeiro, Brazil;
    Type of Paper: Regular
    Id Paper: 360
    Topic: 4

  45. Secondary Metal Raw Materials: Highly Concentrated Open Pit Ores.
     Massimo Maccagni1;
    1ENGITEC TECHNOLOGIES SPA, Novate Milanese, Italy;
    Type of Paper: Invite
    Id Paper: 364
    Topic: 4

  46. Dissolution Of Chromite In Slags
     Rauf Hurman Eric1; Orhan Demir1;
    1UNIVERSITY OF THE WITWATERSRAND, Johannesburg, South Africa;
    Type of Paper: Invite
    Id Paper: 374
    Topic: 4

  47. Revalorization Of Mining-metallurgical Wastes: The Case Of Copper Slags
     Mario Sanchez1;
    1UNIVERSIDAD DE CONCEPCION, Concepcion, Chile;
    Type of Paper: Invite
    Id Paper: 386
    Topic: 4

  48. Production Of Elemental Sulfur: A Promising Alternative For SO2 Abatement From Smelter Gases
     Rafael Padilla1; Fernando Parada1; Arcadio Ulloa1; Juan Carlos Carrasco1; Maria Cristina Ruiz1; Mario Sanchez1;
    1UNIVERSIDAD DE CONCEPCION, Concepcion, Chile;
    Type of Paper: Regular
    Id Paper: 387
    Topic: 4

  49. Recovery Of Metals/Materials From Pyrometallurgical Slags
     Michael Sudbury 1; Jose Palacios2; Mario Sanchez3;
    1MPSCSI, Oakville, Canada; 2UNIVERSIDAD VIñA DEL MAR, Viña del Mar, Chile; 3UNIVERSIDAD DE CONCEPCION, Concepcion, Chile;
    Type of Paper: Regular
    Id Paper: 389
    Topic: 4

  50. Structural Analysis Around Boron And Phosphorous In The CaO-SiO2 Based Slag By MAS-NMR
     Motohiro Sakamoto1; Yutaka Yanaba2; Kazuki Morita1;
    1THE UNIVERSITY OF TOKYO, Tokyo, Japan; 2INSTITUTE OF INDUSTRIAL SCIENCE, THE UNIVERSITY OF, Tokyo, Japan;
    Type of Paper: Regular
    Id Paper: 395
    Topic: 4

  51. Smelting Applications Of DC Arc Furnaces
     Rodney Jones1;
    1MINTEK, Randburg, South Africa;
    Type of Paper: Invite
    Id Paper: 396
    Topic: 4

  52. Feed Material Challenges On The Kumera Steam Dryer
     Jyri Talja1; Shaolong Chen1; Hannu Mansikkaviita1; Ilpo kylmäkorpi1;
    1KUMERA CORPORATION, Riihimäki, Finland;
    Type of Paper: Regular
    Id Paper: 420
    Topic: 4

  53. The Equilibrium Between Titanium And Oxygen In Liquid Fe-Ni, Fe-Cr And Fe-Cr-Ni Alloys
     Seongho SEOK1; Takahiro Miki2; Mitsutaka Hino3;
    1RIST, Pohang, Korea, South; 2TOHOKU UNIVERSITY, Sendai, Japan; 3HOKKAIDO POLYTECHNIC COLLEGE, Hokkaido, Japan;
    Type of Paper: Regular
    Id Paper: 446
    Topic: 4

  54. Feed Forward Control, Optimization And Automation Of Converter Operations
     Mirardo C. Malazarte1; M.G. Variacion2; C.C. Conde2; E.S. Coraza2; L.B. Sinas2; H.E. Lim2; G.G. Laviste2; E. Sayco2; G. Conde2; Redouane Merdjani3; E. OBrien4; S. Llubani3; I. McBow3; Florian Kongoli5;
    1PASAR, Isabel, Philippines; 2PASAR, LIDE, Philippines; 3FLOGEN TECHNOLOGIES INC., Montreal, Canada; 4FLOGEN TECHNOLOGIES INC., Wilmington, United States; 5FLOGEN TECHNOLOGIES INC., Mont-Royal, Canada;
    Type of Paper: Invite
    Id Paper: 448
    Topic: 4

  55. Materials Characterization Of Complex Systems By Applying The Anomalous X-ray Scattering (AXS)
     Yoshio Waseda 1;
    1TOHOKU UNIVERSITY, Sendai, Japan;
    Type of Paper: Plenary
    Id Paper: 453
    Topic: 4

  56. Mechanisms Of Copper Fire Refining In A Packed Bed Reactors
    Gabriel Riveros1; Andrzej Warczok1; Daniel Smith2; Ariel Balocchi3;
    1UNIVERSITY OF CHILE, Santiago, Chile; 2ENAMI, Santiago, Chile; 3ENAMI, Copiapo, Chile;
    Type of Paper: Invite
    Id Paper: 461
    Topic: 4

  57. Influence Of Simultaneous Infiltration And Reaction On The Chemical Degradation Of Magnesia-chrome Bricks In Contact With A Synthetic Lead Slag
     lennart scheunis1; Mieke Campforts2; Tom Jones3; Bart Blanpain4;
    1KATHOLIEKE UNIVERSITEIT LEUVEN (KUL), heverlee, Belgium; 2UMICORE GROUP R&D, 2250 Olen, Belgium; 3KULEUVEN, Leuven, Belgium; 4KULEUVEN, 3001 Heverlee, Belgium;
    Type of Paper: Regular
    Id Paper: 462
    Topic: 4

  58. Applied Mathematics For High Technology And Remote Sensing Applications For The Mining And Metallurgy Industries
     Carlos Perez1; Mario Duran1; Eduardo Godoy1; Pedro Ramaciotti1; Roland Sénéor1;
    1INGMAT, Santiago, Chile;
    Type of Paper: Regular
    Id Paper: 465
    Topic: 4

  59. Production Of Nickel Pig Iron Via Carbothermal Processes Of Lateritic Ores
     cem colakoglu1; Onuralp Yücel1;
    1ISTANBUL TECHNICAL UNIVERSITY, Istanbul, Turkey;
    Type of Paper: Regular
    Id Paper: 468
    Topic: 4

  60. Towards Sustainable Metals Production By Molten Oxide Electrolysis
     Donald Sadoway1;
    1MIT, Cambridge, United States;
    Type of Paper: Invite
    Id Paper: 487
    Topic: 4

  61. New Alternatives For Arsenic Control In Non Ferrous Smelting Developed By University Of Concepción.
     Roberto Parra1;
    1UNIVERSIDAD DE CONCEPCIóN, Concepción, Chile;
    Type of Paper: Regular
    Id Paper: 478
    Topic: 4

  62. Effects Of Mineralogical Characteristics Of Concentrate Blends On Flash Smelting Phenomena.
     Roberto Parra1;
    1UNIVERSIDAD DE CONCEPCIóN, Concepción, Chile;
    Type of Paper: Regular
    Id Paper: 479
    Topic: 4

  63. Energy Consumption In Metal Production
     William Rankin1;
    1CSIRO, TEMPLESTOWE, Australia;
    Type of Paper: Keynote
    Id Paper: 537
    Topic: 4

  64. Anaerobic-aerobic integrated treatment of effluents generated of the process of extraction of chitin and chitosan from crab waste
     Francisco Javier Almendariz Tapia1; MARIA TERESA CERTUCHA2; Onofre Monge1;
    1UNIVERSIDAD DE SONORA, Hermosillo, Mexico; 2UNIVERSIDAD DE SONORA, HERMOSILLO, Mexico;
    Type of Paper: Regular
    Id Paper: 538
    Topic: 4

  65. The Importance Role of Sulfur in Autogenous Copper Smelting Technology
     Ljubisa Misic1;
    1MINING AND METALLURGY INSTITUTE BOR, Bor, Serbia;
    Type of Paper: Regular
    Id Paper: 539
    Topic: 4